Two days after a storm clears Central Florida, the trucks show up. Out-of-state plates, a magnetic sign on the door, a friendly guy with a clipboard working his way down the street while everybody is still dragging branches to the curb.
Let me be fair about this. Not every roofer from out of town is running a scam, and plenty of legitimate companies bring extra crews into Florida after a hurricane because there is genuinely more work than the local guys can cover. But the ones who do damage in this business are the ones who follow the weather: sign as many contracts as they can in three weeks, do the fast parts of the job, and be gone before anyone notices the flashing was never replaced.
The homeowners who get taken are not careless people. They are stressed, their ceiling is stained, the insurance company has not called back, and somebody is standing in the driveway offering to make the whole thing go away today. Here is what I tell my own neighbors to look for.
1. They found you — you didn’t find them
Knocking on doors after a storm is not illegal and it is not proof of anything on its own. But it reverses the normal order of things, and it puts you on someone else’s clock instead of your own.
There is also a specific thing worth checking. Florida law says that when a roofer sends you a flyer, a door hanger, a text, or an email encouraging you to file a roof claim, that communication has to carry three written notices in at least 12-point type: that you are responsible for paying your own deductible, that it is a felony for a contractor to knowingly pay, waive, or rebate a deductible, and that filing a claim with false or misleading information is insurance fraud. If what got left on your door has none of that on it, the person who left it is already ignoring the one law written specifically about how he is allowed to talk to you.
2. The license doesn’t match the name on the truck
Roofing is its own license in Florida — a certified roofing contractor (CCC) or a registered roofing contractor (RC). A handyman does not have one. A general contractor is not automatically the right answer either. You can look any of it up for free at the DBPR license search on myfloridalicense.com, and it takes about ninety seconds.
Search two things: the company name on the contract, and the name of the human being standing in front of you. What you are checking for is whether the license actually belongs to the company you would be paying, or whether it has been borrowed from a qualifier who has nothing to do with the crew that shows up.
Then ask who is pulling the permit. Every jurisdiction in Central Florida requires a permit for a roof replacement. If somebody tells you your job does not need one, or offers to skip it to save you money, you are done — that is the entire conversation. An unpermitted roof is a problem you inherit at closing when you go to sell the house.
3. Somebody offers to “take care of” your deductible
This one is not a gray area and I want to be blunt about it. Under Florida law a contractor may not offer to pay, waive, or rebate any part of your insurance deductible, and doing it knowingly is a felony. It usually arrives dressed up: we will write it off, we will throw in an upgrade instead, we will just build it into what we bill the carrier.
Understand what that person has just told you about himself. He is willing to commit insurance fraud on a claim that has your name on it, not his. When the carrier goes back and looks at the file, you are the policyholder they come to, and he is in another state.
4. The paperwork asks for more than a roof
Read the thing you are being handed. The common move is a contract that is really an authorization — it gives the contractor the right to deal with your insurer directly, commits you to whatever the carrier approves, and adds a cancellation penalty if you change your mind.
Two specifics worth knowing. For property insurance policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2023, Florida no longer allows you to assign your post-loss benefits to a contractor at all. If somebody puts an assignment of benefits in front of you, he has either not kept up with the law or is counting on you not having. And negotiating your claim on your behalf is public adjusting, which requires its own separate license here. A roofer meeting your adjuster on the roof and pointing at damage is normal and genuinely helpful. A roofer acting as your adjuster is not.
5. “This price is only good today”
Roofs do not have flash sales. A real proposal survives a night of sleep, and any roofer who is confident in his number will still be at that number on Thursday.
Ask for it in writing, itemized: the shingle manufacturer and product line, the underlayment, whether the deck is being re-nailed to current code, drip edge, valley detail, ventilation, how many layers are coming off, who hauls the debris, and the length of the workmanship warranty along with who actually honors it. A storm chaser proposal is usually one page with one number on it, because detail is what gets argued about later and they do not plan to be around later.
6. A large payment up front
A deposit is normal. Half the contract before a single bundle of shingles is on your roof is not.
Florida has a rule here that is worth knowing: once a contractor takes more than 10 percent of the contract price as a down payment on residential work, he has to apply for the necessary permits within 30 days of that payment and start the work within 90 days of the permits being issued, absent just cause or your written agreement to a longer timeline. That statute exists because of exactly the pattern we are talking about. Also watch for cash only, a personal check made out to an individual rather than a company, or an invoice with no company name and no license number on it. That is someone arranging not to be findable.
7. Nothing about them is local
A cell phone, no yard, no local office, or an address that turns out to be a mailbox at a shipping store. A website registered five weeks ago. A pile of five-star reviews that all landed the same week.
The real problem here is not only fraud, it is the warranty. A ten-year workmanship warranty from a company that leaves Florida in November is a piece of paper. When a boot cracks in year three, what you want is the person who installed it being a twenty-five minute drive away and still answering his phone.
What to do instead
None of this requires being paranoid. It requires about an hour, most of which is waiting on hold.
- Look up the license at myfloridalicense.com — both the company and the qualifier.
- Ask for a certificate of insurance, general liability and workers’ comp, sent to you directly by their agent rather than as a PDF from the contractor.
- Confirm who is pulling the permit, then verify it with your city or county building department.
- Call your insurance company and open your own claim yourself.
- Photograph your own damage, from the ground, before anyone gets on the roof.
- Get at least one written, itemized proposal from a roofer you went out and found on your own.
- Do not sign anything in your driveway. Nothing good has ever required that.
If you already signed something
If you signed a roof repair or replacement contract within 180 days after the Governor declared a state of emergency, and your property is in the declared area, Florida gives you 10 days from signing — or until the official start date, whichever comes first — to cancel without penalty or obligation. Outside of that window you are looking at the contract’s own cancellation terms, and that is worth twenty minutes of an attorney’s time before you assume you are stuck.
You can also file a complaint against a licensed contractor with DBPR, and report suspected insurance fraud to the Florida Department of Financial Services. We are roofers, not lawyers, so treat this as a starting point rather than legal advice — but do not let embarrassment stop you from making the call. These people count on that.
The boring version is the right one
An honest roofing transaction is genuinely dull. Somebody climbs up, looks at your roof, tells you what is actually wrong with it, writes down what it costs to fix, and then does that. There is no urgency, no free money, and no reason to decide anything before dinner. If the conversation in your driveway feels like a sales close, that is because it is one.
Not sure whether you even have damage yet? Here is what I actually look for on a roof after a storm.
And if somebody already told you that you need a new roof and you want a second opinion from a licensed Orlando roofer who will still be here next year, get a free roof quote from Dusen Roofing. If your roof is fine, I will tell you it is fine.